Skip to content

Hale and hearty after Thanksgiving dinner

By Andy Hollandbeck

Like no other holiday, Thanksgiving revolves around food. For many of us, the day sets visions of roasted turkey and dressing, mounds of mashed potatoes, cranberry jelly, and pumpkin pie dancing in our heads. But many Americans are being more health-conscious these days, creating more balanced and nutritious meals for their family and friends.

Some, I’ve been told, even serve vegetables.

Come Thursday evening, healthful meals like this cause less food coma and more vigor, which leads us to two pairs of often confused words:

HALE VS. HAIL

Hale has two meanings. One, related to the Old French haler “to haul” means, well, “to haul” — or “to compel to go.” This is used primarily in legal contexts. Your uncle’s story about his brush with the law might include being hauled into court, but the official transcript will read that a defendant was haled into court.

The other hale is etymologically related to whole and means “free from defect or infirmity” or “retaining exceptional health and vigor.” This is the type of hale that a well-planned Thanksgiving dinner and a little bit of self-control can lead to. Remembering that the letters in hale are all found in the word health can help you remember the spelling.

Hail fits the bill for most everything else:

  • The balls of ice that fall from the sky, or their falling
  • A salutation (“Hail, good friend!”) or acclamation (“hail to the chief”). Oddly, this word is also related to whole.
  • To greet, summon, or call out to (“Open hailing frequencies”)
  • Hearing distance (“staying within hail”)

HARDY VS. HEARTY

Hardy is, as you might guess, related to hard. It means “robust, tenacious, inured to hardship.” If it withstands violent weather, a barrage of insults, or the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune, it is hardy. Also, if it and its brother solve mysteries together, you might be dealing with one of the Hardy Boys.

Hearty means “vigorous, vehement, or unrestrained” (as in “a hearty endorsement” or “a hearty bellow”) or “exhibiting vigorous good health.” Ironically, while a heart-healthy meal can help a person stay hearty (“exhibiting good health”), all that planning might be for naught if he cannot restrain his hearty (“unrestrained”) appetite.

The link between hearty and heart health ought to help guide you to the correct spelling.

So the idiom you hope to use to describe yourself after a well-balanced and healthful Thanksgiving dinner is “hale and hearty” — and yes, the phrase is basically redundant. That’s idioms for you.

And I hope this Thanksgiving we can all avoid a hardy hail, which could pummel our hardy mums to shreds.

Header photo by Element5 Digital on Unsplash.

This article was originally posted on the Copyediting website, Nov. 23, 2016.

Well, now we’ve punned it. And described it. And headlined it.

Sep 28, 2026

ACES: The Society for Editing names the winners of its 2025-26 Headline Contest.

Read More

Six editors announced as recipients of the 2026 ACES Holden Diversity Fellowship

Sep 23, 2026

September 22, 2026 · By ACES Staff · ACES News Six talented editors have been selected as the seventh class of recipients of the Richard S. Holden Diversity Fellowship, a collaboration of ACES: The Society for Editing and the Dow Jones News Fund. This year’s fellows are Afia Agyapomaa Ofosu, Inez Woody, Jasmine Stole, Stephanie…

Read More

Readers respond more strongly to deeper editing, ACES study finds

Sep 15, 2026

Readers are more likely to notice and value editing when it improves how content is organized, understood, and experienced, according to a new study from ACES: The Society for Editing.

Read More

How to convince your boss to send you to an ACES conference

Aug 26, 2026

You know an ACES conference can leave you with new ideas, stronger skills, and fresh approaches to your work. But getting your boss to approve the investment may require showing how attending can benefit not only you but also your organization.

Read More

A new year for ACES: Reflections and what’s ahead

Jul 16, 2026

A new fiscal year is always a good moment to pause, look back at what we’ve built together, and look forward to what’s coming next. There’s a lot to say on both counts.

Read More

Words, people, and the privilege of serving ACES

Jul 16, 2026

I’ve told the story of my first ACES conference many, many times. Partially because it’s such a fond personal memory, but mostly because it shows how ACES brings editors together and helps them feel like they belong.

Read More

These are my people: Reflections on 30 years of ACES

Jul 8, 2026

ACES had been around for nine years when I first attended a national conference, in Cleveland. What I knew right away (and this has been said many times before) was that these are my people: people who care about the written word, people who care about getting it right for their readers, people who care about their craft and care about how their colleagues are contributing to the common goal of clarity.

Read More

Neil Holdway: A legacy of service to ACES

Apr 25, 2026

Neil Holdway has been part of the ACES Board for more than 20 years.

He joined in 2005 and served as treasurer, secretary, vice president, and treasurer of the ACES Education Fund. He was also the president of the ACES Board.

Read More

Nadia Geagea Pupa wins the 2026 Robinson Prize, the industry’s highest honor

Apr 25, 2026

ACES: The Society for Editing has awarded its 2026 Robinson Prize to Nadia Geagea Pupa.

Read More

Gerri Berendzen named ACES’ 2026 Glamann Award winner

Apr 25, 2026

The Board of Directors of ACES has awarded its 2026 Glamann Award to former ACES Board member and longtime news editor and teacher Gerri Berendzen.

Read More
Scroll To Top